Connect with us

NEWS

Supreme Court Lets Restored Research Grants Keep Flowing

The Supreme Court left a First Amendment block on UC research grant cuts standing after last year’s NIH ruling closed the usual restore-the-money path.

Published

on

The Supreme Court on Nov. 16 refused to hear the Trump administration’s bid to resume cutting University of California research grants. The unsigned denial in Trump v. Thakur, No. 26-210, came three days after the justices’ Nov. 13 conference, and no noted dissent appeared with it.

That silence does more than pause a funding fight. It leaves in place a First Amendment order that exists because the same Court last summer blocked the usual way to put cancelled grant money back on the books.

The Justices Turned the Solicitor General Away

Solicitor General D. John Sauer had asked the Court to decide whether the First Amendment stops the government from weighing the viewpoints in academic projects when it awards or ends competitive grants. The petition sat on the court’s Nov. 16 order list under certiorari denied, with no explanation.

It is unusual for the Court to turn away the solicitor general that cleanly. A rebuff with no noted dissent, issued on a Monday after a Friday conference, is the posture of a Court that did not want the emergency-docket fight this petition was built to restart.

THE DENIAL IN BRIEF

  • The case: Donald J. Trump, President of the United States, et al. v. Neeta Thakur, Individually and on Behalf of All Others Similarly Situated, et al., No. 26-210, from Ninth Circuit case 25-4249.
  • The clock: The petition was docketed on Aug. 19, 2026, listed for the Nov. 13 conference, and denied on Nov. 16.
  • The posture: The order under review is a preliminary injunction, not a final judgment on the merits.
  • The dissents: None of the nine justices publicly noted a dissent.

Claudia Polsky, a lawyer for the University of California researchers, called the denial “terrific news” and said those facts were “all of the best signs one could have that the Supreme Court really did not buy the government’s argument.” The Justice Department said it would “continue to litigate” the lower-court order that still blocks cancellation of certain University of California grants tied to diversity, equity, and inclusion work.

Last Summer’s NIH Ruling Forced a Speech Fight

The trap was sprung on Aug. 21, 2025. In National Institutes of Health v. American Public Health Association, No. 25A103, the Court stayed district-court judgments that had vacated NIH grant terminations worth $783 million. Chief Justice John Roberts and Justices Sonia Sotomayor, Elena Kagan, and Ketanji Brown Jackson would have denied the stay in full. Justices Clarence Thomas, Samuel Alito, Neil Gorsuch, and Brett Kavanaugh would have granted it in full. Justice Amy Coney Barrett supplied the controlling middle.

The August stay in the NIH case said the Administrative Procedure Act’s limited waiver of sovereign immunity does not give a district court power to hear claims based on research grants or to order the government to pay money due under those grants. Challenges to the payments, the Court said, belong in the Court of Federal Claims under the Tucker Act. The same order left in place the part of the Massachusetts judgments that vacated NIH’s internal guidance on DEI, gender identity, and related topics.

The Administrative Procedure Act’s limited waiver of sovereign immunity does not provide the District Court with jurisdiction to adjudicate claims based on the research-related grants or to order relief designed to enforce any obligation to pay money pursuant to those grants.

Supreme Court unsigned order, NIH v. American Public Health Association, Aug. 21, 2025

That split is why Thakur looks the way it does. Neeta Thakur, a University of California physician who studies marginalized communities, had sued in June 2025 with other UC researchers as a class after federal awards were pulled. They pleaded both administrative-law and constitutional claims. Judge Rita F. Lin of the U.S. District Court for the Northern District of California issued a preliminary injunction on June 23, 2025, directing the National Science Foundation, the Environmental Protection Agency, and the National Endowment for the Humanities to restore the grants. Lin wrote that the plaintiffs had a “substantial likelihood that their funding was terminated based on the viewpoint expressed in their grant proposals.”

The Ninth Circuit first refused to pause that order. Then the NIH stay landed the same day, and the government asked the appeals court to look again. In a December 2025 amended order, the Ninth Circuit gave the government part of what it wanted. The speech claim was still alive. The easy restore-the-money claim was not.

Two Classes, Two Different Outcomes

Lin had certified two overlapping groups of University of California researchers. One lost funding through form termination notices that gave no grant-specific reason. The other lost funding under the administration’s DEI-related executive orders. On May 26, 2026, a per curiam panel of Judges Richard A. Paez, Morgan B. Christen, and Roopali H. Desai cut the case along that line, and the mandate issued on July 20.

HOW THE NINTH CIRCUIT DIVIDED THE CASE

Class How the grants were ended What the panel did
Form Termination Class Form letters with no grant-specific explanation Injunction reversed; after the NIH stay, the district court likely lacked power to order the money paid on an administrative-law claim
DEI Termination Class Cuts tied to the DEI executive orders Injunction affirmed; the researchers were likely to show viewpoint discrimination under the First Amendment

The panel said the government may define a subsidy program to match its priorities. It also said that once such a program exists, the government “may not discriminate between speakers within that program to suppress viewpoints with which it disagrees.” Agencies had picked grants for termination based on the recipients’ perceived expression of DEI, DEIA, or environmental justice viewpoints, the judges wrote, “regardless of the programs through which they were funded.”

Because the agencies’ termination of grants was aimed at the suppression of viewpoints with which the government disagrees, it likely violates the First Amendment.

Ninth Circuit panel, Thakur v. Trump, May 26, 2026

That holding, in the Ninth Circuit’s May opinion, is what Sauer took to the justices. The researchers told the Court the case was a poor vehicle, in part because it did not conflict with another appeals court and because the funds at issue had already been awarded through a competitive process. “The government can point to no case where this Court, or any court, has held that the President and federal agencies may terminate grants awarded through a merit-driven competitive process based on the perceived viewpoint of the research,” they wrote.

What the Surviving Injunction Covers

The surviving shield is narrow, and the dollars in the administration’s petition for review make that plain. When the NSF and NEH grants at issue were terminated, about $59 million remained on them, with expiration dates as late as November 2029. Those same NSF and NEH awards had been worth about $150 million when they were made. Those are different figures: unspent balance at the cut, versus original award value.

The University of California system is larger than this injunction. Researchers’ filings put UC grant terminations from Jan. 20 to early June 2025 at more than $324 million, and they said the true total is higher. The petition notes that the UC system took in more than $4 billion in federal grant money in 2024. Rachel Zaentz, a university spokesperson, said the Court’s denial “preserves an important victory for the UC researchers whose critical work and federal grants were targeted” and “supports the principle that research funding decisions should be based on merit, not politics.”

Erwin Chemerinsky, dean of UC Berkeley Law, had urged the justices to deny review. What the denial does not do is write a nationwide rule for every cancelled award. The class is University of California researchers. Since early 2025 the administration has cancelled thousands of grants at NIH, NSF, and other agencies. Scientists outside this class still face the August 2025 holding that a district judge cannot simply order the government to keep paying under the Administrative Procedure Act.

The political objection running under the case is who gets to decide, after an election, which already-awarded projects still deserve public money. Sauer’s filing treats the Ninth Circuit rule as a restraint on every future president who wants to stop subsidizing work that no longer matches administration policy. The researchers treat the same rule as a limit on using the grant spigot to punish a viewpoint after a merit review has already been won. The Supreme Court did not answer that question. It left the temporary order in place while a district court does.

Agencies Cut Grants by Searching for Words

The cuts did not begin in a courtroom. They followed two executive orders issued in the first days of the second Trump term. On Jan. 20, 2025, the president signed a January order ending DEI programs, Executive Order 14151, directing agencies to terminate DEI, DEIA, and “environmental justice” offices, equity-related grants, and related work. On Jan. 21 he signed Executive Order 14173, “Ending Illegal Discrimination and Restoring Merit-Based Opportunity,” which ordered agencies to end race- and sex-based preferences operating under DEI labels and to add anti-discrimination terms to contracts and grant awards.

NIH began terminating research grants on Feb. 28, 2025. NSF followed on April 18. Many of the cancelled projects contained terms the administration said ran against its priorities, including “climate change,” “equity,” and “gender.” Lawyers for the University of California researchers said NSF and NEH carried out the orders by running keyword searches of grant materials and then cancelling awards that used words such as “diversity,” “climate change,” and “gender ideology.”

FROM THE ORDERS TO THE DENIAL

  1. January 20, 2025: Executive Order 14151 directs agencies to end DEI, DEIA, and environmental-justice programs and equity-related grants.
  2. January 21, 2025: Executive Order 14173 orders agencies to terminate race- and sex-based preferences operating as DEI policy.
  3. February 28, 2025: NIH starts terminating research grants.
  4. April 18, 2025: NSF starts terminating research grants.
  5. June 23, 2025: Judge Lin orders NSF, EPA, and NEH to restore University of California grants and provisionally certifies the two classes.
  6. August 21, 2025: The Supreme Court stays NIH grant-payment orders; the Ninth Circuit, the same day, first refuses to pause Lin’s injunction, then later revisits that refusal.
  7. May 26, 2026: The Ninth Circuit keeps the DEI-class injunction and drops the form-letter class.
  8. November 16, 2026: The Supreme Court denies review.

Sauer’s petition argues that holding conflicts with National Endowment for the Arts v. Finley and Rust v. Sullivan, the cases that say the government may fund some activities and not others without having to fund the alternative. In his telling, competitive grant programs already weigh what a project stands for, both at award and at termination, and the First Amendment does not “require taxpayers to continue funding projects that the government concludes no longer serve the public interest.”

The Fight Moves Back to Judge Lin

Because the justices denied review rather than deciding the question presented, the First Amendment issue remains live in the Northern District of California. The Ninth Circuit sent the case back for further proceedings. A final judgment, unlike this preliminary injunction, can be appealed again, and that judgment is the route that could return Trump v. Thakur to the Supreme Court with a full record.

If left to stand, the Ninth Circuit’s decision will establish precedent forcing taxpayers to waste countless dollars on private projects promoting ideologies that their public stewards reject.

D. John Sauer, solicitor general, petition in Trump v. Thakur

Sauer also wrote that the Ninth Circuit rule “interferes with executive-branch priorities in spending taxpayer funds, establishing a dangerous precedent that will hamstring every future administration when seeking to subsidize private projects that promote viewpoints aligned with government policy.” That is the argument the Court declined to take up now. It is also the argument the Justice Department can still make to Judge Lin, and later to an appeals court, once the temporary order is replaced by a final one.

For the researchers inside the DEI class, the practical result is simpler. The NSF and NEH money that was still sitting on those awards, about $59 million when the cuts hit, stays in place while the lawsuit proceeds, on projects that can run as late as November 2029. For scientists whose grants were ended by form letter, or who work outside the University of California class, last August’s NIH ruling is still the binding limit on what a district court can do with an administrative-law claim.

The Justice Department said it would continue to litigate the order that still prevents cancellation of certain University of California research grants the government has labelled DEI initiatives.

Disclaimer: This article is news reporting and legal analysis of a pending federal case. It is for information only and is not legal advice, and it does not tell researchers, universities, or agencies how to handle a grant termination, an injunction, or an appeal. Anyone facing a funding cutoff or considering a claim should consult a qualified attorney who handles federal grant or constitutional litigation. Case status, dollar figures, and court orders reflect the public filings and official actions described here and can change as the district court proceeds.

Harry is the editor of WORLDHAB, an independent publication that he owns and edits himself. His decade in journalism started in reporting and moved into editing, and it left him with a short list of promises that readers can expect every article here to keep. Sources are named and linked, so a claim about a company, a government or a team can be traced to the statement, filing or transcript it came from. Dates are given in full, figures are checked against the original table before publication, and where a number is an estimate the story says whose estimate it is. Headlines describe what happened rather than tease it. Those expectations hold across all ten sections WORLDHAB publishes for an international audience: news, business, technology and science on one side, sports, entertainment, lifestyle and travel on another, with auto and gaming covered with the same seriousness. Harry keeps a public corrections policy and marks every change on the article it affects. Reader mail is read by him and answered from support@worldhab.com.

Click to comment

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Trending