Connect with us

BUSINESS

City Files Warned Before the Flatbush Building Came Down

Eight died when 1321 Flatbush Avenue fell into a 14-foot excavation whose contractor had already paid fines for defying a city stop-work order.

Published

on

A three-story building at 1321 Flatbush Avenue in Brooklyn collapsed into an open construction pit at 4:01 p.m. on November 11, killing eight people. Eighteen others were hurt, including four firefighters, and the FDNY closed the search at 3:37 p.m. on November 12 after determining there were no more victims in the pile.

City files had already logged cracks in that wall, a stop-work order on the lot beside it, and 98 open housing violations in the building that fell.

Firefighters Reached the Pile in Under a Minute

Fire Commissioner Lillian Bonsignore said the call came in at about 4:01 p.m. for a collapse at 1321 Flatbush Avenue, a three-story multiple dwelling that went into an adjacent construction site. Fire and EMS units responded within one minute, and more than 250 firefighters and EMS personnel worked the scene.

Chief of Department John Esposito said one company was already nearby, returning from another run, and drove onto people trapped in the adjoining building. Crews pulled several people from voids, including a woman six months pregnant, who was carried out on a stretcher around 6:30 p.m. Her husband, who had been searching Flatbush Avenue for her, said, “She is alive, she is still alive. I am very happy.”

James Williams, 60, who works at Chelsea Deli Grocery across the street, said he heard what sounded like crews hitting a foundation that morning, then a bang like a gunshot. A few bricks fell. At about 4 p.m. the building came down, and a woman on the interior stairs of the neighbor house slid into the pit with it.

Rain hit the pile on November 12. Bonsignore said the storm would not stop the work. Dogs from the FDNY and the NYPD worked the debris. Heavy equipment came in once the voids had been searched. At 3:37 p.m. the department said rescue operations were finished and turned the site over to the Department of Buildings and the NYPD.

THE TOLL ON FLATBUSH AVENUE

  • Dead: 8 people, including 2 children and 2 construction workers; 6 were pronounced at the scene and 2 died in hospital.
  • Injured: 18 people, 14 civilians and 4 firefighters, with 1 still listed as critical on November 12.
  • Children hurt: At least 7 of the injured are children.
  • Force on scene: More than 250 firefighters and EMS personnel, with K-9 teams from the FDNY and the NYPD.

Esposito warned that 1323 Flatbush Avenue, still standing with its party wall peeled off, remained a secondary-collapse risk while crews were in the hole. The Red Cross and emergency managers opened a reception center at the Flatbush YMCA at 1401 Flatbush Avenue. Flatbush Avenue was closed from Clarendon Road to Bedford Avenue.

Who Were the Eight Victims?

Police released eight names on November 12. Two were children, cousins who lived in the building. Two were adults on the construction job next door. Mayor Zohran Mamdani said the dead included young families and immigrants from Mexico, Colombia, Ecuador, Trinidad, and beyond.

THE EIGHT NAMED BY POLICE

  • Nicole Daniela Salvada Rodriguez, 9: One of the two children killed; her mother is believed to be among the injured.
  • Kevin Santiago Reyes Gonzalez, 10: Nicole’s cousin, also killed in the collapse.
  • Juan Daniel Salvada Guzman, 31: An adult recovered from the wreckage.
  • Ndiaye Mamadou, 31, and Barry Mamadou, 23: Two adults from the same family name on the police list.
  • Gabriel Ariolfo Siguencia Yupa, 22, and Edgar Sapon, 26: Two more of the six adults killed.
  • Jose Luis Caguana Cosquillo, 26: A construction worker who, relatives said, had come from Ecuador about six years earlier and left a 4-year-old son and a pregnant wife.

Mamdani called it a dark evening and morning for the city. Another construction worker, Alvaro Miguel Caizaguano Toasa, a father of two, was among those taken to Kings County Hospital with the pregnant woman pulled from the pile.

14 Feet of Dirt Beside a Cracked Wall

Buildings Commissioner Ahmed Tigani said crews were excavating at 2625 Bedford Avenue when 1321 came down. The lot had an approved plan for a three-story building and a pending filing for nine stories that had not been approved. City records allowed the hole to go 14 feet down. Support-of-excavation and foundation work was listed as permitted as of October 15.

A November 2025 engineering survey filed with the Department of Buildings had already told the project what sitting next to an old house would require.

It is expected that the adjoining buildings abutting the lot line would need underpinning. The required depth of underpinning and the condition of existing foundation may be obtained by excavating test pits next to the respective buildings.

Engineering survey, Department of Buildings filing for 2625 Bedford Avenue

The same survey said the lot would need shoring where no building sat on the property line, and that deep underpinning, if planned, might also need lateral support of existing structures. Public copies of that filing are the document in which the survey says adjoining buildings would need underpinning. Investigators have not said whether that work was in the ground on November 11.

A pre-construction survey dated March 5 described the north facade of 1321 as in poor condition with noticeable cracks, and the west and east facades as fair, also with cracks. Mamdani said he found it incredibly troubling that work kept going after that report. A 311 caller on the afternoon of the collapse alleged the excavation did not follow the approved drawings; the Buildings Department had not ruled on that complaint when rescue ended.

The cheap reading of a $10,000 demolition fine is that the city had already priced the last warning. The costlier reading is that a 1930 joisted masonry wall was left beside an open cellar after the one-story building that had stood against it since 1933 was taken down.

A $12,500 Fine for Defying a Stop-Work Order

N Tech Design of America was the demolition contractor on the Bedford Avenue lot. On March 18 a 311 caller wrote that crews were doing a demolition without a permit and that debris was flying. Inspectors on March 20 found demolition under way with no overhead protection for adjacent properties and issued a partial stop-work order.

When they came back on April 23, the one-story building was gone. The inspector wrote that the firm had continued demolition while on notice of the order, a Class 1 violation. The Buildings Department lifted the order on May 8, writing that demolition was complete and the civil penalty paid.

THE PAPER TRAIL ON 2625 BEDFORD AVENUE

  1. March 20, 2026: Inspectors halt demolition for missing overhead protection on neighboring properties.
  2. April 23, 2026: Reinspection finds the one-story building fully down despite the order; a second violation is issued.
  3. May 8, 2026: The stop-work order is rescinded after the city records the penalty as paid.
  4. May 27, 2026: An OATH hearing on the March ticket ends in an admission and a $2,500 penalty.
  5. July 1, 2026: An OATH hearing on the April ticket ends in an admission and a $10,000 penalty, bringing the two fines to $12,500.
  6. October 15, 2026: Support-of-excavation and foundation filings are listed as permitted.
  7. November 11, 2026: 1321 Flatbush Avenue collapses into the excavation at 4:01 p.m.

N Tech Design later said it had only done the demolition months earlier, not the digging on November 11. Permits for excavation and foundation work were active under other names on the job. After the collapse, the Buildings Department posted a full stop-work order that said unsafe construction operations at 2625 Bedford Avenue had caused 1321 to fall to the ground and onto the site. Officials still describe the cause as under investigation.

Olufemi Falade Was Jailed Once for Neglect

Housing Preservation and Development records listed 98 open violations at 1321 Flatbush Avenue, 21 of them Class C, the immediately hazardous grade. The tickets ran from bedbugs and leaks to unsafe electrical wiring, leaking ceilings, defective fire-retardant material, and missing or broken smoke and carbon monoxide detectors. A 2024 notice said a fire guard had to be posted at once because of a dangerous fire hazard.

The owner on paper is Isolag Realty Corporation. Olufemi Falade is the company’s registered agent. Femi Realty Corp, which Falade has long run, held the deed from 1999 until it transferred the building to Isolag in October 2024.

In 2006, Brooklyn Housing Court Judge Cheryl Gonzales sentenced Falade to 12 days in jail and $50,000 in fines for failing to fix 652 violations at three other Brooklyn buildings. Then-HPD Commissioner Shaun Donovan said the city had spent $175,000 on emergency repairs in Falade buildings and that in just 12 buildings he owned there were more than 1,800 housing-code violations. Donovan called him one of the most egregious examples citywide of forcing residents to live in horrible conditions. The Flatbush Avenue house was not one of the three named in that 2006 case.

Public Advocate Jumaane Williams said his office was looking into disturbing things about the property and the owner, and that the landlord may have been on a worst-landlord watchlist in a recent year. Council Member Farah Louis, who represents that stretch of Flatbush, said a building does not simply collapse in a residential neighborhood without warning signs or systemic failures, and she asked for the inspection records, permits, open violations, and landlord history on 2625 Bedford Avenue.

THE TWO LOTS ON THE CORNER

Address What stood there Who is on the papers What the city already had on file
1321 Flatbush Avenue 1930 walk-up, 3 stories plus cellar, 4 apartments and a ground-floor store; complete collapse Isolag Realty Corporation; Olufemi Falade, registered agent 98 open HPD violations, 21 Class C; March survey of facade cracks
2625 Bedford Avenue 1933 one-story commercial building, demolished in 2026; excavation for a new cellar Robert Fischman of W6 Facility X; N Tech Design of America on the demo; Cheng-Yi Lin Architecture on the filing March stop-work order, April defiance, $12,500 in OATH fines, 14-foot excavation permit

Falade could not be reached in the hours after the collapse. The 98 housing tickets describe how people lived in that house, not, on their face, why the walls came down. The pit next door is the fact investigators have put at the center of the case.

Nine Stories Next Door Had No Final Permit

The Bedford Avenue filing on October 7 was for nine stories plus a cellar, and it still carried objections. Tigani stressed that only the three-story plan was approved and that the work under way was excavation. The larger scheme was a mixed-use building of about 56,000 square feet, with a grocery on the ground floor and 64 apartments above, 13 of them listed as affordable.

The extra bulk leaned on two city bonus programs. One is the Food Retail Expansion to Support Health program, which trades extra residential floor area for grocery stores in neighborhoods short on fresh food; the Bedford filing sought 8,740 square feet of extra residential space that way. The other is the city’s universal affordability preference, which the same papers used for 8,836 square feet of affordable floor area.

None of that height was in the air on November 11. The hole was. Zoning bonuses do not pour footings. They do explain why a one-story lot was being taken down to cellar depth beside a cracked 1930 wall, and why a $12,500 demolition penalty can look small against a 64-unit pro forma.

Inspectors Fan Out to 100 Other Job Sites

Mamdani said five main entities on the Bedford Avenue job are tied to about 100 other construction sites across the city, and that the Buildings Department began sweeping those jobs on November 12. He did not name the five firms. He said a tragedy of this magnitude demands an investigation of both the construction site and the building that collapsed, led by the Buildings Department and law enforcement.

If there is anyone or any entity operating in this city that bears responsibility for what happened, we will hold them fully accountable.

Zohran Mamdani, Mayor of New York City, November 12 press briefing

Brooklyn District Attorney Eric Gonzalez said his office was working with the Buildings Department and other law-enforcement partners to determine whether any criminal conduct contributed. The site, once a rescue, is now in the hands of inspectors and detectives.

WHAT WE KNOW

  • The fall: 1321 Flatbush Avenue, built in 1930, collapsed into the excavation at 2625 Bedford Avenue at 4:01 p.m. on November 11.
  • The count: 8 dead, 18 injured; FDNY ended rescue at 3:37 p.m. on November 12 and said there were no more victims.
  • The file: A March stop-work order, an April defiance, $12,500 in paid fines, a 14-foot excavation permit, and 98 open housing violations on the house that fell.

WHAT IS UNCONFIRMED

  • The cause: A post-collapse stop-work notice blamed unsafe construction next door; officials still say the cause is under investigation.
  • The shoring: The 2025 survey called for underpinning; it is not public whether that work, or the monitors that were supposed to watch the old wall, were in place.
  • The drawings: A 311 caller said the excavation did not match the approved plans; the Buildings Department had not closed that complaint when the search ended.

Neighbors will have a first public date on the calendar at the Community Board 17 meeting on November 18, 7 p.m. at the SUNY Downstate Medical Center auditorium at 395 Lenox Road. The pile on Flatbush Avenue is already a case file. The 100 other sites are where the city says it is looking, after the wall came down, for the next one that has not.

Harry is the editor of WORLDHAB, an independent publication that he owns and edits himself. His decade in journalism started in reporting and moved into editing, and it left him with a short list of promises that readers can expect every article here to keep. Sources are named and linked, so a claim about a company, a government or a team can be traced to the statement, filing or transcript it came from. Dates are given in full, figures are checked against the original table before publication, and where a number is an estimate the story says whose estimate it is. Headlines describe what happened rather than tease it. Those expectations hold across all ten sections WORLDHAB publishes for an international audience: news, business, technology and science on one side, sports, entertainment, lifestyle and travel on another, with auto and gaming covered with the same seriousness. Harry keeps a public corrections policy and marks every change on the article it affects. Reader mail is read by him and answered from support@worldhab.com.

Click to comment

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Trending