Connect with us

NEWS

Brussels Tells TikTok to Stop Ranking Videos by Watch Time

The EU’s first DSA case against engagement ranking tells TikTok to drop watch time from For You, a demand already aimed at Instagram and Facebook.

Published

on

The European Commission said on 6 November 2026 that TikTok’s For You feed breaks EU law by ranking videos on watch time. It wants that signal stripped out of recommendations, or a fine of up to 6% of worldwide turnover.

TikTok called the paper “fundamentally inaccurate” and said it distorts the architecture of the app. The finding is still a charge, not a penalty, and the feed has not been ordered to change yet.

The For You Feed Still Ranks by Watch Time

For You is a continuous stream of personalised clips. The more someone watches or likes a kind of video, the more of that kind arrives next, including clips about sadness, isolation, weight loss and body image. The Commission says that loop can harm mental health, above all for minors and vulnerable adults.

Staff went through TikTok’s own risk reports, internal data, answers to information requests, published research, and interviews with ranking engineers, psychologists and psychiatrists. Ireland’s Digital Services Coordinator, Coimisiún na Meán, backed the work. The paper, issued as IP/26/2361, says TikTok did not adequately assess how that ranking can pull people into what Brussels calls rabbit holes.

When a user keeps watching weight-loss clips, the system reads those taps as interest and serves more of the same. Repeated exposure, the Commission wrote, may raise sadness or anxiety, feed body dissatisfaction and lower self-esteem, or worsen eating disorders and other mental conditions. A Commission official, speaking without a name, said this is the first time the Digital Services Act has been used to take on the engagement-based ranking model itself, and that mental health was the file because the evidence there was strongest.

Every time a user scrolls or likes a video on TikTok, the algorithm serves more of the same leading users down rabbit holes they cannot easily escape from. The Digital Services Act makes platforms responsible for addressing the negative effects related to their recommender system. Today’s preliminary findings show again that TikTok needs to step up its efforts to protect users’ well-being, including those of minors.

Henna Virkkunen, Executive Vice-President for Tech Sovereignty, Security and Democracy, 6 November 2026 statement

Virkkunen’s line is a product claim, not a post-by-post takedown. The next clip is chosen because you lingered, and Brussels wants that choice treated as a risk the company failed to measure.

Four Changes Brussels Wants in the Ranking Engine

At this stage the Commission says TikTok needs to change the design of the For You feed. The examples are specific, and one of them goes to the core of short video: disable viewing time as a signal for what to recommend next.

THE FOUR RANKING CHANGES BRUSSELS LISTED

Demand What it would change on For You
Rely more on explicit preferences Stated choices would weigh more than passive watching
Disable viewing time as a ranking signal How long a clip is watched would no longer count as a vote for more of the same
Make user controls easier to find and use Taps that say “see less of this” would have to steer the feed
Test the algorithm regularly The ranking would face ongoing checks, not a one-off settings page

Those four points sit on a duty already written into Regulation (EU) 2022/2065 of 19 October 2022. Very large platforms must weigh the design of their recommender systems when they assess systemic risks, including serious harm to physical and mental well-being, and they must put in place measures that are reasonable, proportionate and effective.

If the Commission later confirms its view, it can issue a non-compliance decision. Article 74 lets it set a fine that is not more than 6% of the provider’s total worldwide annual turnover in the preceding financial year, scaled to the nature, gravity, recurrence and duration of the breach. No amount has been proposed. TikTok Technology Limited is the designated service; the cap is on that provider’s worldwide turnover, not a number Brussels has billed.

TikTok’s Existing Buttons Did Not Break the Loop

TikTok already built tools meant to interrupt rabbit holes. The Commission’s second finding is that those tools are not effective. Diversified recommendations, it said, do not cut how often similar clips, including mental-health and body-image clips, keep arriving. Control tools do not give users real command of the feed.

The sharp example is the Not Interested button. Using it, the paper says, may not be enough to change what comes next, because the ranking still puts viewing time above a user’s choice to see less of a topic. A Commission official put it more bluntly: saying “I’m not interested” has to have an effective meaning, and cannot be an afterthought before the old ranking returns.

HOW THE CURRENT TOOLS FALL SHORT

  • Topic mixing: Extra variety still leaves similar clips, including body-image and mental-health clips, coming at a high rate.
  • Not Interested: The tap does not reliably rewrite the next stack of videos.
  • Watch time: Time spent on a clip outranks an explicit request to see less of that topic.
  • Feed refresh: A Commission official said the refresh is temporary and the old loop returns after a short pause.
  • Non-personalised option: The Digital Services Act requires a feed that is not based on profiling, and an official said only 0.2% of TikTok users turn that option on.

TikTok points at a different figure. The company said more than 79 million EU users used Not Interested or keyword filters in the first half of 2026. That is a count of people who touched the tools, not proof the tools rewired ranking, and it is a separate number from the 0.2% who pick the non-personalised feed.

Lab work already sat in that gap. In June 2026, Northeastern University researchers found that a Not Interested tap beat a simple swipe in most test runs, yet rejected topics can return within minutes once accounts stop marking them. Piotr Sapiezynski, a professor on the study, said that if a button claims to do a job and does not do it, that is a dark pattern under the Digital Services Act. The Commission’s file, built on internal data rather than a campus test, now says the same mismatch is a legal failure.

A TikTok spokesperson said the company has “a strong record of protecting our community while giving users direct and intuitive control over their content experience.” Direct, in Brussels’ reading, is the problem. The feed still treats lingering as a truer preference than a tap that says stop.

Proceedings Opened in 2024 Still Have Not Produced a Fine

The rabbit-hole paper is one slice of a file opened on 19 February 2024, more than two and a half years before this charge. TikTok was designated a very large online platform on 25 April 2023. The Commission’s own docket lists the service with 135.9 million average monthly users in the Union, under Ireland as coordinator.

Brussels has accused TikTok of breaches more than once and has not fined it. Advertising transparency closed with binding commitments on 5 December 2025. Other slices of the same 2024 proceedings produced earlier papers and then this one.

THE TIKTOK DSA DOCKET

  1. 25 April 2023: Commission designates TikTok as a very large online platform.
  2. 19 February 2024: Formal proceedings open on addictive design, rabbit holes, minors, ads and researcher access.
  3. 15 May 2025: Preliminary findings on the advertising repository.
  4. 24 October 2025: Preliminary findings on access to public data for researchers.
  5. 5 December 2025: Commission accepts TikTok’s advertising-transparency commitments and closes that limb.
  6. 6 February 2026: Preliminary findings that infinite scroll, autoplay, push alerts and a highly personalised ranking amount to addictive design.
  7. 24 July 2026: Preliminary findings that TikTok failed to keep minors’ accounts safe.
  8. 6 November 2026: Preliminary findings that the For You ranking creates harmful rabbit holes and that current fixes do not work.

The February paper and the November paper are easy to mash together and should not be. In February the Commission went after infinite scroll, autoplay, night-time use by minors, and screen-time tools it called easy to dismiss. Nine months later it isolated the ranking logic of For You and named viewing time. One file, two design fights: how long the session lasts, and which clip is chosen inside it.

Instagram and Facebook Already Face the Same Theory

TikTok is the first service charged on the engagement ranking model in those words. It is not the only feed Brussels has told to become less hungry for attention. On 10 July 2026 the Commission issued a parallel paper on the addictive design of Instagram and Facebook, aimed at infinite scroll, autoplay, alerts and highly personalised ranking.

That Meta file asks for autoplay and infinite scroll to be off by default, for screen-time breaks that actually hold, and for a ranking system that is less engagement-oriented. The TikTok file asks for viewing time to drop out of For You. Different apps, same theory: the way the next item is picked is a systemic risk, not a pile of bad posts to be taken down one by one.

That is why the 6 November charge travels. YouTube Shorts, Instagram Reels and Snapchat all rank short video by how people watch. A confirmed duty to stop treating watch time as a vote would not stay inside one Chinese-owned app. Creators who live on binge loops would lose the mechanism that made a clip spread past their followers, and advertisers who buy that attention would be buying a colder feed. The political counter is already in the open: that health language is being used to rewrite a ranking business Europe never replaced with a home-grown rival.

What a Feed Without Watch Time Would Do

If viewing time is barred as a ranking input, For You can no longer treat a pause as a request for more of the same topic. Explicit taps, follows, searches and stated interests would have to do more of the work, and a Not Interested mark would have to stick. The non-personalised option, now used by 0.2% of users, would no longer be the only escape from profiling. Nothing in the 6 November paper orders that change today.

WHAT WE KNOW

  • The charge: Risk assessment and risk mitigation on For You both fail, in the Commission’s preliminary view.
  • The ask: Redesign the feed, including dropping viewing time as a recommendation signal.
  • The cap: A later non-compliance decision can bring a fine of up to 6% of worldwide annual turnover.
  • The process: TikTok may inspect the file and reply in writing; the European Board for Digital Services will be consulted.

WHAT IS UNCONFIRMED

  • A final ruling: The paper does not prejudge the outcome, and no date is set for a decision.
  • A live redesign: For You is unchanged while the defence runs.
  • A billed fine: No figure has been proposed, and TikTok has not been fined under this file.

TikTok now has the right to go through the investigation papers and answer in writing. Until that answer lands, and until Brussels either drops the charge or makes it final, the ranking that built the product remains the ranking in the app.

Harry is the editor of WORLDHAB, an independent publication that he owns and edits himself. His decade in journalism started in reporting and moved into editing, and it left him with a short list of promises that readers can expect every article here to keep. Sources are named and linked, so a claim about a company, a government or a team can be traced to the statement, filing or transcript it came from. Dates are given in full, figures are checked against the original table before publication, and where a number is an estimate the story says whose estimate it is. Headlines describe what happened rather than tease it. Those expectations hold across all ten sections WORLDHAB publishes for an international audience: news, business, technology and science on one side, sports, entertainment, lifestyle and travel on another, with auto and gaming covered with the same seriousness. Harry keeps a public corrections policy and marks every change on the article it affects. Reader mail is read by him and answered from support@worldhab.com.

Click to comment

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Trending