NEWS
A Delayed Salary Cap Would Spare Baseball’s Biggest Spenders
MLB’s Nov. 3 offer delays a $258.2 million cap until 2028, giving eight over-cap clubs one more luxury-tax season after the union said no.
Major League Baseball offered on Nov. 3 to delay a hard salary cap until 2028, after free agency for next season had already opened. The union rejected the package the same day.
The wait would leave 2027 under the current luxury tax, which is the part of the offer that actually moves money. Eight clubs above a proposed $258.2 million ceiling would get one more uncapped season. Twelve clubs below a $180.2 million floor, including both 2026 pennant winners, would wait another year to be forced to spend.
A One-Year Stay for Baseball’s Biggest Payrolls
Spokesman Glen Caplin said clubs need a full offseason to get inside a cap-and-floor band, and that this winter is already too far along. Some 2027 books already sit near or above the ceiling the league wants. Others would have to buy in a hurry to hit the floor. So the league asked the union to begin the cap and floor system in 2028, the second year of a new deal.
“This proposal would allow a smoother transition into the cap and floor system without delaying key player benefits, including earlier free agency, a $1 million minimum salary, a 30% increase to the pre-arbitration bonus pool, and transactional reform that will reduce roster churn,” Caplin said.
With free agency already underway, and recognizing that Clubs will need a full offseason to operate within the cap and floor system, MLB is proposing to phase in the salary cap and floor in 2028
The projected cap and floor payrolls for 2028 would make 12 clubs increase payroll… pic.twitter.com/EfMErTa1Jo
— MLB (@MLB) November 3, 2026
The new ceiling is up nearly $13 million from the league’s first figure of $245.3 million. The floor is up $9 million from $171.2 million. Both numbers are projections tied to 2027 revenue, and they count benefits the way the luxury tax already does. Amateur signing bonuses would stay outside the count. In 2028 the league wants a 50-50 split of what it calls baseball revenue and wants national media money centralized. For 2027 it would keep the present revenue-sharing plan and the $244 million luxury tax threshold that is already in force this season.
That is the hinge. A club that wants to load up this winter would still face the same tax rates as in 2026, including 50 percent for third-time payers, not a hard stop. A club that wants to stay cheap would still be allowed to.
Eight Clubs Would Have to Cut $528 Million
MLB said eight clubs would have to reduce payroll by a combined $528 million to get under the 2028 cap, using 2026 end-of-season luxury-tax books. The group is the Dodgers, Mets, Yankees, Phillies, Blue Jays, Padres, Red Sox and Cubs. Twelve clubs would have to add a combined $636 million to reach the floor. The league’s own arithmetic on those two figures is a net payroll increase of $108 million.
Independent 2026 competitive balance tax payrolls show how far the top of the list sits from $258.2 million. The Dodgers finished at $433.1 million and a tax bill of $183.4 million after a 100-62 season. The Mets, at $359.5 million, went 74-88 and missed the playoffs. The Yankees were at $341.9 million and 93-68.
THE EIGHT CLUBS OVER THE PROPOSED CAP
| Club | 2026 tax payroll | 2026 record |
|---|---|---|
| Dodgers | $433.1 million | 100-62 |
| Mets | $359.5 million | 74-88 |
| Yankees | $341.9 million | 93-68 |
| Phillies | $322.2 million | 88-74 |
| Blue Jays | $315.8 million | 79-83 |
| Red Sox | $271.2 million | 87-75 |
| Cubs | $269.2 million | 89-73 |
| Padres | $264.6 million | 91-71 |
A public ceiling for 2028 still shapes this winter even if the cap itself waits. Long deals signed now will count then. The eight clubs can spend in 2027, but they cannot pretend the next offseason is open-ended, which is why the delay is a stay and not a blank check.
Milwaukee and Tampa Bay Finished Below the Floor
The floor list is the other half of the ledger, and it is the half the league uses to sell competitive balance. MLB named the Marlins, Guardians, Cardinals, Rays, Nationals, White Sox, Twins, Rockies, Pirates, Athletics, Reds and Brewers as the twelve that would have to spend more. Two of those clubs just played for the title.
Milwaukee won the World Series at $154.7 million on a 103-59 payroll. Tampa Bay won the American League at $113.2 million and 98-64. Cleveland’s tax book was $92.6 million. Miami’s was $84.4 million. A hard floor in 2028 would make those clubs write checks they did not write this year. A delay means they do not have to write them this winter either.
The floor is not a one-year cliff. A club could operate at 90 percent of the line in 2028, which is $162.18 million, if it spent the full $180.2 million over a three-year span. That still leaves the Guardians and Marlins a long climb. It also leaves the Brewers, who just won a title, on the same side of the line as clubs that have not.
Trevor Megill, the Brewers closer, had already drawn that map before the Nov. 3 session. “A salary cap is not going to work for anybody in the union. Good luck trying to get it,” he said on Oct. 23.
Low-payroll clubs are the hidden losers of a later start if the point of the floor is to make them buy. Their owners are the hidden winners of the same delay if the point is to avoid a forced shopping spree. The eight clubs above the cap get 2027 either way.
What the 2027 Season Would Still Change
Caplin’s list of player items would start in 2027, not 2028, if the union took the deal. They are the bait. They are also narrower than the headlines on them.
PLAYER ITEMS THAT WOULD START IN 2027
- $1 million minimum: The figure applies to players with at least two years of service; everyone under two years would get $900,000, up from $780,000, plus $100,000 from the bonus pool if they bank a full year and spend less than half the season on the injured list.
- Bonus pool: The pre-arbitration pool would rise 30 percent from $50 million in 2026 to $65 million in 2027, then to $75 million over a seven-year deal running through 2033.
- Five-year free agency: The six-year reserve, in place since 1976, would drop to five years for 30-year-old players, with the club able to tender a one-year deal at the average salary of the 125 highest-paid players; MLB said 48 percent of players with five years of service this past season would have reached the market a year sooner.
- Qualifying offer: The draft-pick penalty tied to the qualifying offer would go away for other free agents.
- Roster churn: Optional assignments per season would fall from five to four, a fourth option year would end, weekly rosters would block in-week options and outrights, and Rule 5 protection would move up a year.
- One-time bonus: 2026 luxury-tax money that now funds later 401(k) contributions would be paid out as service bonuses of $285,000 for a full year on a 187-day season, then $213,400, $142,300 and $71,100 for three-quarters, half and a quarter.
- Minor-league minimums: Initial big-league deals would rise from $63,600 to $73,400, and later contracts from $127,100 to $146,700.
MLB called the jump to $1 million the largest year-over-year raise in the minimum in baseball history, about $100,000 larger than the previous record. The $1 million line still covers a thin slice of the roster, because players reach arbitration after three years. An earlier league offer had also floated a 154-game season and a best-of-seven Division Series. Those items were not the center of the Nov. 3 paper.
Players Rejected the Delay on the Same Day
The union did not treat 2028 as a concession. It treated the cap as the same system with a later on-switch, and it said 2027 is not a clean year under the old rules. On May 27 the union had asked for a higher tax line, near $300 million, and no cap. The Nov. 3 answer still required a cap.
Coming off another incredible season of baseball, MLB owners continue to propose blowing up the current system and replacing it with one designed to line their pockets and increase their franchise values.
Major League Baseball Players Association, Nov. 3 statement
The same statement said a delayed cap still means a large cut in player pay, an end to rights that include guaranteed contracts, a gutting of amateur entry, and a zero-sum pool that “harms the middle class and pits player against player.” Even the so-called transition year, the union said, would bring immediate limits on contract rights, frozen luxury-tax thresholds, a $400 million cut in amateur signing bonuses, and a loss of competitive edges that smaller-market clubs now hold. Players, it added, still want a deal that does not line their pockets and increase franchise values for the clubs.
Agent Seth Levinson of ACES, speaking after the session, said he had not seen this level of player solidarity since 1994. Joel Wolfe of The Team put the cap itself in one line: “Over our dead bodies are we going to accept a cap and further restraints on salaries.”
The 1994 Strike and the Lost World Series
Owners have not put a hard cap on the table in a finished deal since the fight that stopped the 1994 season. That strike ran seven and a half months and cancelled the World Series. The last work stoppage was a lockout, not a strike, and it ended on the 99th day in March 2022, when the current five-year agreement was signed.
HOW THE LAST TWO STOPS ENDED
- 1994: Players strike over a salary cap; the World Series is cancelled.
- March 2022: A 99-day lockout ends with a five-year deal and no cap, with a luxury tax that now sits at $244 million.
- May 27, 2026: The union’s opening paper seeks earlier free agency for 30-year-olds, an end to the qualifying offer, and a higher tax line with no cap.
- Nov. 3, 2026: MLB offers to wait until 2028 for a $258.2 million cap and an $180.2 million floor and to start the player items in 2027.
- Dec. 1, 2026: The current agreement expires at 11:59 p.m. ET.
Bruce Meyer, the union’s interim executive director, said in June that a cap is “a form of institutionalized collusion” and that owners, not players, locked the sport last time. Caplin has kept the league on the other sentence: fans, he says, want a flatter field, and a 50-50 split with a floor would get more clubs into the market. The Nov. 3 paper did not close that gap. It moved the date.
The Current Agreement Expires on Dec. 1
Nothing in the new offer extends the present deal or keeps the offseason open past Dec. 1. Free agents can still sign until then. If the league locks the union at 11:59 p.m. ET, those deals stop and the 2027 calendar slips with them. MLB said it is willing to talk about other phase-in dates. The union’s Nov. 3 statement did not offer a cap date of its own.
The eight clubs above $258.2 million are the ones the delay actually protects through 2027. The Brewers and Rays are the ones it leaves unforced. The current agreement expires at 11:59 p.m. ET on Dec. 1, with the cap still on the table and no new player paper in reply.
-
ENTERTAINMENT3 months agoRolex Made Drake the Daytona It Fights Jewelers Over
-
BUSINESS3 months agoTreasury’s First Iran Bank Shot Lands on an Ally
-
NEWS3 months agoInstinct’s $2.5 Billion Raise Still Binds the User as Agent
-
NEWS3 months agoCity’s £125m Enzo Deal Caps a £327m Midfield Rebuild
-
ENTERTAINMENT3 months agoRicky Gervais Wants Alley Cats to Run Until He Dies
-
NEWS3 months agoMeta’s Teen Settlement Leaves Chat Off the Clock
-
NEWS3 months agoCSIRTs Inherit Europe’s Missing security.txt Before Article 14
-
BUSINESS3 months agoBerkshire Anchors Alphabet’s Record Raise With a $10 Billion Check
