We’ve all wondered about it. Who would win in a fight between Spider-Man and Daredevil? Well, thanks to Your Friendly Neighborhood Spider-Man, the latest animated series under the Marvel Cinematic Universe (MCU) umbrella, we finally have an answer—sort of. And let’s just say, fans are very opinionated about how it went down.
The Fight That Had Everyone Talking
The moment aired in one of the newest episodes of Your Friendly Neighborhood Spider-Man, featuring a younger Peter Parker clashing with a more seasoned Matt Murdock. Naturally, the internet had a lot to say.
The official Twitter (or X) account for DiscussingFilm posted about the battle, and the comment section quickly turned into a battleground of its own. Some fans were thrilled, calling it one of the best Spider-Man depictions in years. Others? Not so much.
- @dbz96_rob shared a positive take: “I thought this show was gonna suck I’m glad it seems like I was wrong. I’ve heard way more good about it than bad.”
- @DinoKohli pushed back against the criticism, saying, “Damn people are really negative on this show huh? I haven’t held back criticizing marvel Disney plus shows for being worse than the pre-2019 marvel shows… But this show is easily the best Spider-Man we have had since Spectacular easily.”
The fight was definitely a highlight for many, but it wasn’t without its flaws.
A Clash of Titans—With Some Animation Woes
One of the biggest complaints from viewers? The animation. While Your Friendly Neighborhood Spider-Man has been largely well-received for its fresh take on Peter Parker’s early days, the way fight scenes are animated left some fans scratching their heads.
There’s no denying that the show has a distinct visual style, but when it comes to high-speed, hand-to-hand combat, it seems to struggle. The pacing, movement, and overall execution of the Daredevil vs. Spider-Man brawl didn’t land as smoothly as some had hoped.
That said, the nostalgia factor saved it for a lot of people. The decision to bring back the Daredevil Netflix series’ music for Matt Murdock’s entrance? An undeniable win.
Did the Writers Get It Right?
Then there’s the bigger debate: should Daredevil really be able to give Spider-Man a run for his money?
On paper, Spider-Man has superhuman strength, speed, agility, and reflexes. He’s lifted cars, dodged bullets, and taken down enemies way stronger than Daredevil. Meanwhile, Matt Murdock, while highly skilled, is still just a human with heightened senses and expert martial arts training.
So, realistically, Spider-Man should have an edge. But the fight wasn’t necessarily about who’s stronger—it was about skill, experience, and tactics. Daredevil has years of crime-fighting under his belt, and Peter is still finding his footing. From that angle, the outcome makes sense.
MCU’s Handling of Classic Rivalries
This isn’t the first time Marvel has sparked debate with superhero matchups. Fans are still arguing over who really won in Captain America: Civil War. The same goes for Hulk vs. Thor, Iron Man vs. Captain America, and even the various versions of Spider-Man we’ve seen over the years.
What makes fights like these compelling isn’t just raw strength—it’s the strategy, the personalities involved, and the circumstances. While Your Friendly Neighborhood Spider-Man may not have nailed the animation, the concept of pitting Peter against Matt was a smart choice.
And let’s be real—bad animation or not, seeing these two iconic heroes clash was still a moment worth watching. Because even if the execution wasn’t flawless, a Spider-Man vs. Daredevil fight is like ice cream. Even when it’s not perfect, it’s still pretty sweet.
